This is the first place we hit when in Tarrytown. It is a small mom and pop style deli with a broad sandwich menu. The prices are good, and the sandwiches are incredible. Today was cold and rainy, so I ordered a coffee. It was excellent, and the price was about half of the price at a "coffee" joint.

Yelp never steers me wrong. I needed catering for a work event and I prefer only to use the local businesses. I found Dominic's and reached out to the owner to coordinate our lunch event for 50 people the following day. My coworker and I got ourselves sandwiches when we went in to place the order and his response was "I'm going to have to unhinge my jaw to eat this incredible sandwich." Needless to say the food was outstanding and the people that work at Dominic's are awesome. I'll definitely be back! Thanks again!

The owners are always friendly, fun people. The food is tasty at a great price point, just make sure to come early because they sell out some ingredients later in the day. I've had the two grilled chicken special sandwich types, and one sandwich on a hero is enough food for me for a whole day (and I eat a ton of food). The sesame hero is a great bread btw. Honestly, my favorite though has to be the healthy breakfast B or #2 or something, on a spinach wrap. Perfect combo of sliced turkey, egg whites, tomatoes, and feta. Highly recommend it, and the place in general

Fantastic spot. Super friendly staff and delicious food at very affordable prices! Loved my sandwich and would definitely come back.

As always, great sandwiches at a great price! Almost always stop in here when I'm in tarrytown and get an Italian sandwich or the #5 sandwich special. Friendly service and large portions!

Great deli! Fresh ingredients and sandwiches made to order! They have a full breakfast menu and all the cold cuts for a hero you can imagine! The bread is fresh and soft with a little crisp. Just what you want for a hero! The hero is huge and reasonably priced for how packed the sandwich is! I got soppressata, prosciutto, mozz, roasted peppers and arugula on a hero for $12. Can't beat it! They also have some salad and imported pantry items for all your Italian needs! The staff is super helpful and friendly. Would definitely recommend if you are craving a nice hero!

Went there twice while visiting NYC. I want them to open one down the street from us in IN so I can be a regular. So much charm and the quality of meat is top notch. The pastrami is nothing like we can get here. They know their regulars by name and even recognized us on our second visit.

Fantastic NY deli that I'd come back in a heartbeat! First off, amazing staff...the lady behind the counter taking our order was friendly and funny and helped us navigate ingredients when they ran out of some of the sandwiches, while the gentlemen making the sandwiches were truly connoisseurs. I really wanted the Signature #5 but the last one was ordered right in front of me (ugh!). Instead, I ordered an Italian hero while my wife ordered the Hot Roast Beef (Signature #2 - w/ Muenster cheese, hot peppers, grilled onions). Of course we had to add a mac salad side. Both sandwiches were delicious - well seasoned and loaded with the fixings. The mac salad was excellent. We should have ordered a pint! Very reasonably priced and even better given how big the sandwiches were (~$28 after tip for 2 large heroes and the mac). We will have to make a special trip back just to try the #5!

This place is plucked from the movies. This is exactly what a real New York deli is and should be forever and ever!! The woman behind the counter really makes the whole experience-- with her New York accent, friendly but not overbearingly friendly small talk, and no-BS vibe. A great place to stop in if you need a "why do I live in New York?" reminder. Good prices, super fresh rolls, perfectly seasoned sandwiches. Also convenient- some pantry items, especially of the Italian variety. You can't go wrong here. There is a small high-top counter if you'd like to sit and eat inside, but I'd recommend taking it to-go and enjoying the park down the street.

Sandwich Heaven. We found it passing by. You name it, they have it, from Italian specialties like Mortadella with pistachio, Coppa and Dilusso Soppresata, to a nice tea selection, and even non-sandwich classics like LPs! You can build your own or choose from their "Signature" set. Mind you, the sandwiches are HUGE...both of ours could feed two people each. I had the #5 Signature - chicken cutlet, prosciutto from Italy, mozzarella, roasted red peppers and balsamic. On a roll for $9.95. Weighs in at 250lbs :) See pic. My wife had a turkey and Swiss (no pic) that included an entire turkey! Both delicious. Friendly service topped it off. We need a deli like this in our town in Florida.